Turbidity & suspended solids instrumentation, historically based in Port Townsend, WA Product line now supported through Campbell Scientific, Inc.
A bold yellow angular logo mark set against a deep dark background, sharp and modern
D & A Instruments
Turbidity monitors & water-quality instrumentation

How Air Bubbles Distort Optical Suspended-Solids Readings

Optical suspended-solids sensors estimate the concentration of particles in water by measuring how light is scattered or absorbed within a sensing volume. This approach is widely used for turbidity, sediment transport, dredging plume assessment, hydrology and process monitoring. It provides rapid, high-frequency data, but the optical signal responds to anything that changes the way light travels through the sample.

Air bubbles are one of the most common sources of interference. A bubble can scatter light far more strongly than the mineral or organic particles being measured, producing a sudden increase in apparent turbidity or suspended-solids concentration. The effect may last for milliseconds as a bubble passes the optics, or continue for hours when aeration, wave action or poor installation repeatedly introduces gas into the measurement zone.

Why bubbles create false optical signals

Optical instruments generally use a light source and one or more detectors positioned at defined angles. Suspended sediment particles scatter some of the emitted light towards the detector. The instrument converts the received intensity into a turbidity or solids estimate using a calibration relationship. A bubble changes this geometry because its gas–water boundary has a large refractive-index difference.

The result can be a strong reflection, refraction or scattering event. A single large bubble may create a sharp spike, while a cloud of fine bubbles can raise the baseline and make the signal appear consistently elevated. Bubbles can also block the light path, causing a temporary reduction in received light. Depending on the sensor design and signal-processing method, this may be interpreted as either an unusually high concentration or an invalid reading.

The error is especially significant when the actual sediment concentration is low. In clear water, a small number of bubbles can dominate the optical response. In very muddy water, the relative influence of each bubble may be smaller, although bubbles can still cause unstable readings, detector saturation and poor repeatability.

Where entrained air enters the measurement

Breaking waves and surface turbulence are obvious sources of bubbles, but they are not the only ones. Water flowing past a structure can experience local pressure changes that release dissolved gas. Pumps, valves, weirs, propellers and poorly sealed intake lines can introduce air, even when the surrounding water looks calm. Dredging equipment can entrain air through suction disturbances, discharge flows and vessel movement.

In Australian field work, this matters across very different settings. A sensor deployed near a coastal dredging project in Moreton Bay may experience bubbles from vessel wash and turbulent discharge, while an instrument in the Murray–Darling Basin may see aeration below a regulating structure. In the tropics, intense rainfall and cyclone-driven runoff can deliver highly aerated water to creeks and estuaries within a short period.

Bubbles may also form on the sensor itself. Warm water, changing pressure and biological activity can promote dissolved-gas release. A rough, fouled or hydrophobic optical window provides places for bubbles to attach. Once attached, a bubble can remain in the optical path much longer than a free-floating bubble and produce a sustained bias.

Recognising bubble interference in the data

Bubble contamination often has a distinctive time-series appearance. Short, isolated spikes that return rapidly to the previous baseline commonly indicate individual bubbles passing the optics. Repeating bursts may correspond to waves, pump cycles, propeller revolutions or tidal turbulence. A sudden increase that coincides with rainfall, a gate opening or dredge movement may reflect genuine sediment mobilisation, bubble interference or both.

Comparing optical output with other measurements helps separate these causes. A pressure sensor, acoustic instrument, flow record, conductivity probe or second optical channel can provide useful context. If the apparent solids concentration rises sharply while flow, backscatter from another path or water chemistry remains unchanged, bubbles become a likely explanation. Video inspection of the deployment site can also reveal persistent aeration that is invisible in a short site visit.

Good records include the sensor depth, orientation, flow direction, pumping state, weather, vessel activity and maintenance history. Australian projects often span remote locations, from Pilbara ports to northern Queensland rivers, so field notes and timestamped photographs can be as valuable as laboratory checks. A flagged data interval is preferable to treating every unusual peak as a sediment event.

Selecting a better installation position

Installation is usually the first and most effective mitigation step. The sensing path should be placed in representative water, away from the surface where wave action entrains air and away from outlets, pumps, sharp bends and structures that generate turbulence. A moderate distance downstream of a disturbance may provide better mixing, but the sensor should not sit inside a recirculation zone where bubbles collect.

Orientation also affects bubble behaviour. A sensing face angled slightly downward can discourage bubbles from settling directly over the optical window. The correct angle depends on the instrument design, current direction and mounting hardware. The sensor must still remain accessible for cleaning and should not be positioned where sediment can accumulate on the optics.

For fixed stations, a stilling arrangement, bypass flow cell or protected sampling chamber can reduce the effect of surface turbulence. These solutions must be designed carefully: excessive damping can remove genuine sediment fluctuations, while a narrow inlet can clog or alter the particle distribution. In tidal Australian estuaries, the installation should be checked during both flood and ebb flow because a position that behaves well in one direction may collect bubbles during the other.

The manufacturer’s technical information is a useful starting point when planning a deployment. The D & A Instruments site provides background on optical monitoring technologies and the types of environments in which these systems have been applied.

Managing bubbles in pumped and bypass systems

A bypass or flow-through arrangement can give operators more control over the water presented to the sensor. The sample line should avoid drawing from a visibly aerated layer and should be sized to maintain a stable flow without excessive velocity. Smooth bends, tight seals and gradual changes in diameter help prevent air entrainment. Where practical, the sample should enter below the water surface and remain flooded throughout the system.

A degassing chamber, settling section or vertical separator may remove free air before the sample reaches the optical cell. The design must account for particle behaviour, since aggressive degassing or long residence times can allow coarse sediment to settle. This changes the sample and may create a different error from the bubbles being removed. For suspended-solids monitoring, the aim is to remove gas while preserving the concentration and size distribution of the water being measured.

Pumps require particular attention. Peristaltic pumps, diaphragm pumps and centrifugal pumps each impose different shear and pressure conditions. Leaking suction lines are a frequent cause of apparently mysterious bubbles. Clear tubing can assist commissioning, although it may encourage algae growth during long deployments. In industrial or OEM installations, an air-release point, pressure gauge and inspection port can make troubleshooting much easier.

Using signal processing without hiding real events

Digital filtering can reduce the effect of individual bubble strikes. Median filters are often effective against short, isolated spikes because they reject extreme values while retaining a broader trend. A rolling percentile, rate-of-change limit or persistence rule can also identify readings that are physically unlikely for the site. These methods should preserve the raw signal so that unusual events remain available for later review.

Averaging reduces random bubble noise, but the interval should match the monitoring objective. A one-minute average may be suitable for a broad dredging-plume trend, while it could conceal a short discharge event or an important peak near a sensitive habitat. In Australian environmental approvals, data may need to demonstrate compliance with a threshold over a specified averaging period, so the processing method should be agreed with the project regulator and documented before deployment.

Quality flags are more informative than silently replacing suspect values. A record can distinguish valid data, probable bubbles, sensor fouling, saturation, maintenance and communication failures. An optical sensor with multiple detectors or wavelengths may offer additional diagnostic information, but extra channels do not eliminate the need for sensible installation and inspection.

Calibration should be based on representative water and operating conditions. Formazin or other reference materials can verify instrument response, but they do not reproduce every bubble and particle effect found in a river, harbour or dredge plume. Site-specific samples analysed for total suspended solids can reveal whether an apparent optical increase corresponds to actual mass concentration.

Field maintenance and verification practices

Regular cleaning is essential because biofilm, silt films and organic deposits change the optical path and can trap bubbles. The inspection interval should reflect the site: a clear inland dam may require less attention than a productive estuary, a wastewater channel or a tropical river. Cleaning should follow the sensor manufacturer’s instructions so that the window is not scratched and seals are not damaged.

Before deployment, inspect the body, cable, connectors and mounting frame for pockets where air could be trapped. Wetting the sensor gradually and gently moving it underwater can help release attached bubbles during commissioning. After installation, allow the instrument to equilibrate before accepting data, particularly when it has been moved between air-conditioned vehicles, warm surface water and deeper water.

Verification visits should compare the optical reading with a known reference or a properly collected water sample. Collecting samples during calm and turbulent conditions can show whether the instrument has a bubble sensitivity that is specific to one operating state. If a field sample is taken, record depth, time, flow condition and nearby activity; suspended sediment can change rapidly during a storm or dredging cycle.

For remote stations, telemetry alarms can identify sudden signal volatility, a persistent baseline shift or readings that exceed the instrument’s normal range. This is valuable for sites where access involves long travel, boat work or safety controls, such as ports around Port Hedland or flood-affected stations in northern New South Wales. Automated alerts should prompt inspection rather than automatically labelling every high value as bad data.

Applying the strategy to monitoring programmes

The appropriate response depends on the purpose of the measurement. A dredging contractor may need rapid warning of a plume crossing a boundary, whereas a researcher studying seasonal sediment transport may prioritise long-term stability and event capture. An OEM integrator may need a compact air-tolerant assembly, diagnostic outputs and defined cleaning intervals. The same optical principle can serve all three applications, but the installation and data rules will differ.

Application-specific planning should consider water depth, salinity, particle mineralogy, organic content, current speed and the likely source of aeration. Coastal construction in Western Australia may involve vessel wash and sediment-rich seawater; a monitoring station near the Great Barrier Reef may need to distinguish storm-driven turbidity from bubbles in shallow reef water. Inland systems can present different problems, including algal material, low flow and air release below hydraulic structures.

Technical application notes and monitoring examples can help align the sensor, mounting method and data workflow with the site. D & A Instruments’ monitoring applications cover the kinds of environmental and marine use cases where optical suspended-solids measurements must be interpreted in context.

A reliable programme treats bubble control as part of measurement design rather than a post-processing fix. Sound placement, secure plumbing, clean optics, event-aware filtering and independent verification work together. When these measures are combined, optical suspended-solids data can remain responsive to genuine sediment movement while avoiding the false alarms created by passing or attached air bubbles.